• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Pizza Mania NJ: The Ultimate Destination for Delicious Pizza

At Pizza Mania NJ, located in Garfield, we pride ourselves on crafting delicious pizza and paninis that keep our customers coming back for more. Our story begins with a commitment to quality ingredients and authentic flavors. From the tangy vodka chicken wrap panini to hearty veal pasta dishes, each menu item is thoughtfully prepared and bursting with taste. We cater to everyone, offering a variety of vegetarian options, outdoor seating, and even a dog-friendly environment. With a welcoming atmosphere and exceptional service, Pizza Mania NJ aims to be your go-to spot for both quick takeout and leisurely meals with family and friends.

Pizza Mania NJ at a glance

  • Address 390 Midland Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026
  • Phone (973) 859-0855
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Pizza Mania NJ: Reviews & Ratings

Ayla S
5

So happy to have discovered this gem! They have a great selection of pizzas to choose from. I'm obsessed with their Caesar salad pizza and will be continuing to frequent this location!

J Centeno
5

Just recently moved to NJ and this is a excellent pizzeria with so much variety of food. After living here for a few months this is my go to pizzeria for pretty much anything me or my wife is craving for lunch or dinner. During the day they have an excellent variety of slices on display and everything I have tried is delicious. The takeout picture is of a specialty salad and a penne alla vodka with grilled chicken. Whatever you are craving they cook and even if you are trying to eat healthy they have so many options including delicious wraps and salads and so much more! Calling the restaurant is always easy and efficient, Take out is always on point, delivery is fast (No delivery fee, but always take care of the driver delivering your food) and all staff have been great and friendly thus far.

M A
5

The variety of different types of available slices that Pizza mania has is incredible. I really enjoyed the buffalo pizza they have. The place is very clean and there is seating available. There is also an ice cream shop linked next to the store which is have to try out.

Sagarika. Rana
5

Their single slice gourmet slices are amazing. For some reason they had shrimp teriyaki pizza with avocado tomatoes arugula and onion... And for some reason it was kind of some of the best shrimp teriyaki I've ever had? Also pictured is their drunken Grandma square Pizza which is also fantastic! Super quick turnaround and their parking situations not bad at all. Will definitely come back!

Arli Lika
5

I really appreciate a good, tasty pizza and Pizza Mania never disappoints. The crust has that perfect crunch with just the right amount of chew, and the toppings always taste super fresh. Their pastas are flavorful and comforting, and the salads are surprisingly amazing too fresh, crisp, and a great balance to the pizza. It’s the kind of place you look forward to going back to because everything feels made with care. Definitely one of my favorite spots.

jeffy paul
5

Came to this place today for the first time. Don't let the prices fool you. I got scared when I saw them, but let me tell you after I tried their specialty slice, I believe it was teriyaki chicken. It was way underpriced best specialty Pizza around. Definitely recommend this place. I'll be definitely coming back here

Des KF
4

Decided to get lunch from this restaurant. I ordered the chicken marsala and mussels. When I arrived I parked in the small lot. I walked in and was greeted. The food was ready, and I paid and left. When I dug in, the mussels were delicious! It was seasoned to perfection. I also liked the chicken marsala pasta. I definitely enjoyed it, and it was super affordable.

Sarah DeRosa
5

Best pizzarea / restaurant around truly! Love the food, it’s always fresh! Pizza mania never disappoints. The staff is kind and attentive, orders are always correct. They have these awesome magnets that are just the cutest too! Love this place so much. Moved a few times and regardless of how far I move I always manage to stop by this place to eat or order when I’m in the area. Love you guys thank you for the amazing food and amazing workers! Lovely people! Yummy food!

Location

  • Pizza Mania NJ
    Pizza Mania NJ
    390 Midland Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026 Hotline: (973) 859-0855

Welcome to Pizza Mania NJ! Nestled in the heart of Garfield, New Jersey, at 390 Midland Ave, this lively pizzeria expertly crafts delicious and innovative dishes that cater to all tastes. With a relaxed yet vibrant atmosphere, Pizza Mania NJ offers a variety of dining options including delivery, takeout, and outdoor seating. Whether you are looking for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a gathering with friends, this eatery has got you covered.

What sets Pizza Mania NJ apart is their dedication to quality and flavor. The extensive menu features everything from classic pies to gourmet creations. Customers rave about the vodka chicken wrap panini, which one happy patron declared to be “the best wrap ever.” The savory blend of blackened chicken and exquisite vodka sauce has quickly made it a fan favorite.

For those craving pizza, you’re in for a treat with their diverse selection. Highlights include:

  • Caprese Pizza: This refreshing option boasts fresh sliced tomatoes and homemade mozzarella, drizzled with olive oil and garnished with basil.
  • Chicken Caesar Pizza: A perfect combination of grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, and Caesar dressing, served on a crispy crust.
  • Potato and Onion Square Pizza: Satisfying sautéed potatoes and Spanish onions topped with mozzarella, a unique twist worth trying.
  • Sicilian Square Pizza: With its classic dough and richly seasoned toppings, this pie is a tribute to traditional flavors.

Not just limited to pizza, Pizza Mania NJ also serves delicious pasta, mouthwatering burgers, and vibrant salads. Many customers emphasize the freshness of the ingredients and the generous portions that leave them satisfied. One diner noted, “Incredible meal! Huge portions. Delivered in minutes and very fresh and hot.”

Pizza Mania NJ embraces a friendly and welcoming approach; families will delight in their kid-friendly options, while groups will appreciate the ample seating and catering services. The restaurant is also equipped with free Wi-Fi and on-site parking for added convenience.

Next time you're near Garfield, NJ, make sure to stop by Pizza Mania NJ. With their outstanding service, exceptional dishes, and an inviting atmosphere, it's a dining experience you won’t want to miss!

For inquiries or to place an order, reach them at (973) 859-0855.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards